Introduction is progressing, but proof is not keeping up

Qantas reportedly signed an AI contract with Accenture and cut approximately 850 jobs. Around the same time, AI stocks plummeted in the wake of the election, and banks and investors became wary of AI-related debt. In drug discovery, funding and collaboration announcements continue to precede results. Both personnel and funds are being mobilized before the effects of AI can be confirmed in numbers. Explanations such as ``It's because of AI'' or ``Thanks to AI'' are likely to be prepared before reading. As I read this half-day article, I wanted to find out what the causes of each report were and whether those causes were verified. The fact that a connection has been reported and the fact that cause and effect have been confirmed are treated as different things.
Australian airline Qantas has reportedly cut around 850 jobs after signing an AI deal with Accenture (Quartz India). Because the company name, number of people, and contract are listed, it's tempting to read it as an example of AI stealing jobs. But this report goes so far as to link cuts to AI contracts. It is unclear from the information in the title how much of the work the contract will replace or how many of the 850 employees were directly affected by AI. There is a difference between there being a connection and confirming that AI is the cause.
There is another view. Analysts say the economy, not AI, is the main driver of tech layoffs (TradingView). Even though the word "reduction" is the same, the causes are different between what happened alongside the AI contract and what happened as a result of the economic downturn. When these two reports are placed side by side, there are points that readers can confirm. The three points to consider are whether the reductions were announced before or after the introduction of AI, whether the companies themselves were citing AI as the reason, and whether there was any evidence of economic deterioration during the same period. It can be said that explanations based on AI can only be verified after such confirmation.
There are also movements surrounding human resources. The Singapore Economic Development Board (EDB) shares expert views on generative AI and the future of work. Universities are reportedly incorporating AI into classes without hiring new students as companies seek AI skills (Higher Ed Dive). The concrete fact is that the existing system is being used without increasing the number of teaching staff. These moves are in line with the promise that AI will change the nature of work, but they do not mean that the promise is backed up by employment statistics. It is appropriate to accept the opinions of experts as nothing more than opinions.

